The children were fed, clothed and kept warm, but the vast majority had never experienced any form of sensitive care on an emotional level. Her father worked in a factory as a flight mechanic during World War II and continued in aviation afterward, and her mother, who was around 20 years younger and from an Oklahoma farming family, had come to southern California as a teenager with family friends fleeing the Dust Bowl. Basingstoke, Hampshire, United Kingdom: Case studies usually obtain fascinating evidence about the human mind, the unique circumstances of them lead to the usually unethical or impractical evidence for us to gather and analyse, yet they do not always have to be ungeneralisable. Throughout linguists’ testing, the size of Genie’s vocabulary and the speed with which she expanded it continued to outstrip all anticipations. For legal reasons, all of the names in the film were changed.

The findings of the study were that the adopted children fared better than the ‘restored’ children in that they tended to form closer attachments to their adopted parents than the ‘restored’ children did to their natural parents. Genie returned to live with her mother, but when she couldn’t cope, Genie was placed in more foster homes where she was abused further. Their development was normal. Archived PDF from the original on February 26, Hospital staff were reluctant to give foster custody to Butler and were very skeptical of her story, strongly suspecting she had concocted it as part of a bid to take over as Genie’s guardian and primary caretaker, but decided that placing Genie in an isolation ward at the hospital could potentially be highly damaging to her social and psychological development, so they agreed to temporarily quarantine her in Butler’s home. The study of Genie’s brain aided scientists in refining several existing hypotheses regarding brain lateralization, especially its effect on language development. Journal of the Acoustical Society of America.

He almost never allowed his wife or son to talk and viciously beat them if if did so without permission, particularly forbidding them to speak to or around Genie. You are commenting using your Google account. The case study of Genie is famous for two reasons, the first being just how extreme her social isolation was. Her gehie living arrangements became the subject of rancorous debate.

Studies like this have very high ecological validity as there are no variables that have been manipulated.

Genie (feral child) – Wikipedia

Typically, research into privation uses the case study method to due to the obvious ethical issues of deliberately separating a child from their mother.

Evaluating the case of the Czech Twins Although the case of the Czech twins seems to show that the effects of privation can be reversed by providing a caring, sensitive and loving attachment figure, there are some important evaluation points that must be considered when making such a conclusion: He argued that this interfered with providing Genie the best possible care and compromised their objectivity, which in turn contributed to the case study’s lack of coherence, and both he and Harlan Lane emphasized that making David Rigler a foster parent accelerated this breakdown.


Are the effects of maternal deprivation as dire as Bowlby suggested? It was through the analysis of feral children case studies, in particular Anna Davis, and Davis, and Isabella Mason, that Davis hypothesised that intensive language acquisition training is instrumental for the recovery of children lacking speech through social isolation.

I think that case studies could be improved if the studies were able to be replicated, so that the study is still insightful and detailed but also more researchers could study whether the results could then be generalised.

privation the case study of genie

Case Study of Genie. However, she still had a hard time being with large crowds of people; at her birthday party, she became so anxious at all the guests present that she had to go outside with Rigler to calm down.

Case Study of Genie (the feral child) by on Prezi

Retrieved February 12, Ggenie would be my opinion that case studies are an excellent form of gathering in-depth information on a subject. Genie is a classic case study and has had a large amount of influence on the theories of privation. During this period, he almost always kept her strapped to a child’s toilet or bound her in a crib with her arms and legs immobilized, forbade anyone lf interacting with her, provided her with almost no stimulation of any kind, and left her severely malnourished.

These each have different effects, argued Rutter. Stydy is a shame that case studies take so long, yet the rich and detailed information that they produce really do seem to be worth the wait, as well as the money.

privation the case study of genie

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Researchers believed Butler had good intentions for Genie, but criticized Butler’s unwillingness to work with them and thought she negatively affected Genie’s care and the case study. They also continued to observe her in everyday conversations to gauge what pragmatics of language she acquired. The findings of the xtudy were that the adopted children fared better than the ‘restored’ children in that they tended to form closer attachments to their adopted parents than the ‘restored’ children did to their natural parents.

Jean Butler, who married shortly after authorities removed Genie from her house and began using her married name, Ruch, stayed in touch with Genie’s mother. By mid she could accurately name most objects she encountered, and clearly knew more words than she regularly used.



Curtiss also recalled one time when, while she and Genie were walking and had stopped at a busy intersection, she unexpectedly heard a purse emptying; she turned to see a woman stop at the intersection and exit her car to give Genie a plastic purse, even though Genie had not said anything. Following her discovery she was adopted by psychologists who researched her at the same time as giving her intensive stusy in developing language skills, teaching her to walk, and trying to educate her.

Privation of attachment and institutionalisation What happens to a child’s social and intellectual development when they do not have the opportunity to form an attachment to a caregiver? This sleep pattern continued for several months after being taken away from her father. On the same day Genie went back to the hospital, the Riglers had Genie transferred to their home in Los Feliz.

Though ancient and medieval texts made several references to language deprivation experiments peivation researchers labeled such ideas “The Forbidden Experiment”, impossible to carry out for ethical reasons.

Case studies in psychological research.

She became somewhat more sociable in her interactions with people and became somewhat more responsive, although she still frequently showed no obvious signs that she heard someone. Famous case studies such as Anna O.

Authorities then moved her into the first of what would become a series of institutions for disabled adults, and the people running it cut her off from almost everyone she knew and subjected her to extreme physical and emotional abuse. The scientists believed Genie was often unaware of her pronunciation, but on other occasions she produced haplologies which were clearly intentional and would only speak more clearly if firmly, explicitly requested to; Curtiss attributed the latter to Genie trying to say as little as possible and still be understood.

Upon determining that Genie had not yet learned language, linguists saw Genie as providing an opportunity to gain further insight into the processes controlling language acquisition skills and to test theories and hypotheses identifying critical periods during which humans learn to understand and use language.